October 7 and its aftermath: A view from Kurdistan and the Kurdish Diaspora

Hamas' attack on Israel played a pivotal role in Turkey's and Iran's longstanding imperialist strategy to destabilize the Middle East. Since then, they have been emboldened in myriad ways.

Since the cross-border assaults launched by Hamas on Israeli civilians and military sites on October 7, 2023, the Gaza war has spilled over into a broader war with far-reaching implications for the entire region and its people, particularly Kurds across the Middle East, who are more vulnerable because they are stateless. Yet, this war appears to be less of a Palestinian war and more of an imperial and Islamist war fueled by the Turkish and Iranian regimes. These regimes, together with their Shia and Sunni-Islamist proxies, manipulate and abuse Palestinian narratives, along with the ensuing humanitarian crisis, to pursue imperial and colonial objectives in the Middle East, both expanding their power territorially as well settling these territories with their own peoples and other peoples serving their interests, for example the Palestinians moved by the Turkish regime to Afrin. They celebrate the Sunni jihadist group Hamas and its genocidal, ISIS-like methods, which include, but are not limited to, the fetishization of women’s rape, murder, and the mutilation of civilian corpses, all of which aim to instill fear and force people to flee their homes and neighborhoods. Hamas and other jihadist groups justify these atrocities by citing Islamic decrees against “infidels,” including Jews and Kurds. Concurrently, their sponsoring Iranian and Turkish regimes pursue hostile policies against the Kurdish forces in Rojava (Northern Syria) in particular and, to some extent, target the forces of the Kurdistan Region of Iraq as a “defense” against “Zionist agendas,” which they demonize and blame for the region’s crisis and human tragedy in Gaza. And by blaming Israel for the humanitarian catastrophe, the Turkish and Iranian regimes seek to manipulate Kurdish opinion to incite animosity toward Israel and promote antisemitism.

Many Kurdish journalists and activists at home and the diaspora view the Hamas massacre on Israeli civilians on October 7, 2023, and Turkish and Iranian attacks on the Kurds as a continuation of the Islamist and imperialist war against secular and non-Islamist indigenous communities in the Middle East. On social networks, some Kurdish individuals referred to a connection between Hamas, Turkey, and ISIS, as well as their Islamic objectives. These jihadist groups, notably the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS) and Al-Qaida-affiliated entities, launched the initial Islamist war against the Kurds in Iraq and Syria in mid-2014, relying on weapon supplies, jihadist recruitment, and financial support from Turkey. On the other hand, the competing Iranian regime has deployed its Shia extremist proxies based on a similar ideological line. Due to ideological ties and common interests, both regimes sponsor Hamas in an attempt to undermine the processes put in motion by the Abraham Accords  and the ISIS defeat by the Kurds that would ultimately pave the road to a multi-cultural and tolerant Middle East.

The Turkish and Iranian regimes exploit Hamas as a Palestinian “representative,” serving as an extremist ally for their ideological and political expansion. Both regimes’ objectives are to restore the imperial legacies of the Shia Safavids and Sunni Ottoman Empires. To this end, they undoubtedly played an indirect role in the pre-October 7 assaults by providing Hamas with shelter, funding for terrorism, and intelligence. Nevertheless, it is unknown to what degree these regimes were directly involved in Hamas’ planning and execution of the October 7 attacks. What is clear is that the same regimes have played a significant role in the post-October 7 era, launching military, diplomatic and lobbying campaigns to elevate Hamas as the Palestinian people’s representative and legitimize its carnage against Jewish people. The Iranian regime has deployed proxies from its “axis of resistance network” in Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, and Yemen to launch attacks against Israel, American military sites in Iraq and Syria, and Kurds in both countries. Then, on April 13, 2024, Iran launched direct ballistic missile and drone attacks on Israel, escalating the crisis. Similarly, the Turkish regime has actively backed Hamas in regional and international diplomacy via donations, lobbying efforts, and propaganda. In this context, the Turkish president has accused Israel of being a “terror state” that commits “crimes against humanity,” likened the government to the “Nazi regime,” and placed sanctions on the import of significant products into Israel. Erdogan also hosted Hamas leaders in Istanbul on April 20, 2024, refused to classify them as a terrorist group, calling them instead a “liberation movement.” He urged Hamas leaders to forge unity while criticizing Western nations’ persistent support for Israel. He seeks to present Hamas as “the Palestinian voice” in international politics. The Turkish regime also exerts pressure on Middle Eastern and European states to take a more favorable position toward Hamas and recognize its legitimacy. Yet Hamas acts of war, backed by both regimes, have ultimately escalated the battles with the IDF, resulting in the deaths of tens of thousands of Gazan civilians, the destruction of the Gaza Strip, mental suffering and traumatization among Israelis, and Israel’s economic downturn.

Iran’s actions have some unique dimensions. As part of its defensive foreign and domestic agendas in the region, the regime has persistently pursued a strategy of chaos and destabilization to export conflicts from its borders into rival nations’ territories. The Mullahs were thus able to ignite a conflict within Israel, far from its borders, by backing Hamas and its atrocities militarily before and after October 7. The Iranian regime believes that Israel is attempting to encircle and isolate Iran by normalizing its relationships with Arab nations under the Abraham Accords and reinforcing its friendships with Azerbaijan and Turkmenistan. Furthermore, trade and energy projects, such as the Israel-Gulf Railway and Pipeline and the India-Middle East-Europe Corridor (IMEC), circumvent and isolate Iran. Domestically, the regime has faced a political and economic crisis as a result of the protests sparked by the execution of the Kurdish woman, Jina Amini, in 2022, as well as unrest among the domestic Kurdish, Baloch, and Azeri populations. The authoritarian regime in Tehran regards these incidents as part of a Western conspiracy against its existence. In response, it has adopted a destabilization strategy, mobilizing its proxies, including Hamas, to undermine the Arab-Jewish peace process, the IMEC, and the Arab-Israel oil and gas pipeline. It also aims to overcome its geopolitical, economic, and political isolation, aiming to establish regional hegemony and leadership in the Muslim world.

The regime’s doctrines of Islamic radicalism, particularly pan-Shia Islamism and Persian imperialism, also influence its strategy. While the desire for the revival of the Safavid empire connects with Persian imperialism, pan-Shia Islamism stands in opposition to Western culture and worldview. Therefore, the Mullahs’ ideology rejects ethnic and national identities while promoting antisemitism, anti-Zionism, and anti-Kurdish bigotry. The Islamic Republic of Iran’s anti-Israel attitude is one of its fundamental principles. Thus, the Iranian regime recruits, equips, and mobilizes hardline “revolutionary” proxies—such as Hezbollah, based on ideological Shia affinity, or Hamas based on common objectives—to coordinate covert and overt operations against these “enemies.” Despite repressive Iranian politics, the Kurds have continued to fight the regime, most recently in the form of a women’s revolt following the killing of Jina Amini, under the motto “jin jiyan and Azadî”—women, life, and freedom.

Notwithstanding its lower profile than Iran in the West, the Turkish state has capitalized on Palestinian narratives, via its ideological connection to Hamas as part of the Muslim Brotherhood, to oppose the new Middle East heralded by the Abraham Accords. Instead, it pursues a subversive imperial agenda. The Hamas assaults provided Erdogan with critical leverage in the Middle East to foster imperial, expansionist, and Islamist Turkish aspirations against the multi-national order of the Abraham Accords, with the ultimate goal of seizing regional Islamic leadership and reinstating the Muslim world’s Ottoman spirit. Furthermore, the Turkish president has used the Gaza war to divert its citizens’ attention away from Turkey’s economic crisis and to advance, in the context of the breakdown of the IMEC (India-Middle East-Europe) corridor, its foreign policy objective of an alternative corridor in collaboration with Iraq, Qatar, and the UAE, claiming that “there can be no corridor without Turkey.” The Erdogan regime has also advocated for the suspension of normalized ties between Israel and Arab countries.

The Turkish state also takes advantage of the Gaza War and international attention to attack Kurdish forces and civilian infrastructure in Rojava, diverting the Kurds from their fight against ISIS and other jihadist groups. Rojava is two things at once. First, it is the backbone of the struggle against Sunni and Shia pan-Islamism and imperial expansions represented by the Turkish and Iranian regimes, as well as radical jihadist orders imposed by ISIS and Al-Qaida-linked groups. It is also a model for secular values and the peaceful coexistence of multi-ethnic and multi-religious communities in the Middle East, all of which serve to promote and reinforce peace for the Jewish people and Israel’s security. Yet, in conjunction with the Hamas massacre, the Turkish and Iranian states escalated their direct and indirect assaults against Kurds in Rojava. The Turkish attacks have already inflicted massive damage to civilian infrastructure and killed hundreds of Kurdish citizens in Rojava. The regime justified these strikes by referring to the demonized “Zionist project.” For example, the Aydinlik Newspaper, associated with the Erdogan regime’s ultranationalist coalition, published an article headlined “If Palestine Wins, Kurdistan Loses; If Kurdistan Wins, Palestine Loses.” According to this article, Israel’s primary objective is to construct a second Israel under the flag of Kurdistan. It equates the creation of Kurdistan with the establishment of a second Israel. The depiction of Kurdistan, dehumanized by the Turkish regime as “Terroristan,”, serves to reaffirm Turkish anti-Kurdish hostility and antisemitism and legitimize Turkish repression of the Kurds. These manifestations of misleading information and misconceptions about Jews and Kurds are the result of Turkey’s rising antisemitism and anti-Kurdish nationalism. Yet, Erdogan’s regime fosters antisemitism in the Kurdish community through the HÜDA PAR (Free Cause Party), a legal extension of the Turkish version of Hezbollah in Kurdistan that operates in the range of Erdogan’s AKP (Justice and Development Party) in the Turkish Parliament. The Turkish Hezbollah, which is unrelated to the Lebanese militia, has already murdered many Kurdish civilians on behalf of the Turkish state in the 1990s. This Turkish approach seeks to instill distrust and antagonism between the Kurdish people in Turkey and Jewish people in Israel and the diaspora while also eliminating the positive perceptions that have existed among the Kurds towards Jews for decades. Thus, both regimes, despite their historical, ideological, and geopolitical divergences, have equally and effectively taken advantage of the human suffering in Gaza to embark on a disinformation campaign about Kurdish-Jewish ties as part of a larger antisemitic and anti-Kurdish strategy and propaganda. These strategies of manipulation and division to stifle any support for Kurdish groups claiming cultural and political autonomy have been a constant of Turkish, Iranian, and Arab state policies since World War I.

Throughout history, the Kurds have suffered tremendously under imperial powers. Believed to be descendants of the Medes, an ancient people, the Kurds have lived in an area between eastern and south-eastern Anatolia and Mesopotamia for a few thousand years. Until the turn of the twentieth century, numerous empires, including the Safavids and the Ottomans, controlled their territories. The Kurds responded by seeking autonomy and/or collaboration—the choice of most indigenous groups in the region. Kurds, like other subjugated ethnic groups, had the opportunity to achieve independence with the fall of the Ottoman Empire after World War I, and the Paris Peace Conference in 1919 discussed plans for a Kurdish state. Tragically, the Kurdish chieftains were unable to unite sufficiently to uphold their vision against Turkish, Arab, and Iranian imperialists who sought Kurdish territory for their own states. European colonial forces thus supported the imperial claims of the larger ethnic groups in the region, despite the wartime promises they made to the Kurds. Ethnic Kurds were divided between the Turkish, Iranian, Iraqi, and Syrian states in the various post-WWI treaties. The failure to create an independent Kurdistan after WWI resulted in the perpetual denial of Kurdish cultural identity, political rights, and statehood. Since then, the Kurds have suffered permanent persecution, forced assimilation, displacement, and exile from their homeland by secular nationalist and religious Sunni and Shia rulers, as well as Islamist and nationalist proxies among the three traditionally imperial ethnic groups of the region—the Arabs, the Turks, and the Iranians. Currently, the Kurds rank as the second-largest stateless ethnic group in the world, behind the Tamils. The Kurdish Institute of Paris estimates that there are more than 45 million Kurds worldwide (20 million in Turkey, 12 million in Iran, 8.5 million in Iraq, 3.6 million in Syria, and more than 2 million in the diaspora). However, the lack of precise statistical and official data on the number of Kurds worldwide challenges these estimates.

Since the formation of modern Turkey in 1923, successive Turkish regimes have subjected the Kurds to genocidal policies, forced assimilation, and mass deportation. These include, but are not limited to, the Zilan massacre in 1930 and the Dersim genocide in 1938, which resulted in the killing of thousands of Kurds. Throughout the 1990s, the Turkish state evacuated over 3,000 Kurdish villages, deporting millions of their inhabitants from their homes. It initiated, via JITEM, the military intelligence department of the Turkish Gendarmerie, the formation of the Turkish Hezbollah at the beginning of the 1990s. This group went on to assassinate and kidnap thousands of Kurdish civilians. Under the Erdogan regime, from the mid-2000s until today, the Kurds have continued to endure unprecedented levels of oppression, including the arbitrary imprisonment of thousands of Kurdish politicians and journalists, as well as the constitutional ban on the Kurdish language. For example, when the Kurdish MPs occasionally speak Kurdish in the Turkish parliament, the Turkish officials and policymakers designate the Kurdish language as a “unknown language” and mark it accordingly with an “x.” Furthermore, the Turkish state not only denies Kurdish identity, but also actively conducts cross-border attacks against Kurdish people in Rojava and the Kurdistan Region of Iraq (KRI) on a regular basis, intensifying its attacks especially after October 7 as it takes advantage of the Gaza war to target the Kurds. In the context of anti-Kurdish campaigns, the Turkish regime has depopulated the Kurdish inhabitants in Afrin and other towns, replacing them with extreme Islamist entities, including Palestinian Islamists. The forced migration of Kurds from Afrin at the hands of the Erdogan regime has been described by multiple NGOs, including Amnesty International, and UN Agencies,  as “ethnic cleansing” and “war crimes.” Hamas praised the seizure of Afrin and other Kurdish towns, congratulating Erdogan on the “liberation of the Muslim land.” In its ongoing anti-Kurdish military assaults, the Turkish army has murdered thousands of Kurdish civilians alone through its airstrikes in Iraq and Syria.

Since World War I, Kurds in Iran have experienced the repressive policies of both the Pahlavi Dynasty and the Mullah regime. The Mullah regime—like the Pahlavi dynasty, which assassinated and hung Kurdish leaders and activists from the 1920s until its demise in 1979—has rejected Kurdish demands for autonomy since coming to power, alleging that these demands are a Marxist-inspired Western plot against the Islamic Republic of Iran. As such, Khomeini proclaimed a jihad—a “holy war”—against the Kurds, analogous to the 1988 anti-Kurdish Anfal campaign of the Ba’ath party in Iraq and the Turkish jihadist operation against the Kurds in Syria, and branded the Kurdish movement “the party of Satan.” Khomeini’s holy war claimed the lives of more than 10,000 Kurds via mass executions. Thousands of Kurds sought asylum in neighboring and European countries. It also targeted and executed Kurdish exile leaders in Europe, most notably in Vienna in 1989 and Berlin in 1992. At present, Kurdish political prisoners, accused of espionage for Israel, continue to face the death penalty. In the Kurdistan Region of Iraq, the Mullah regime has also, since the beginning of the 2020s, conducted airstrikes against Kurdish activists, refugees, and their families.

Finally, the Kurds of Iraq and Syria have encountered the genocidal acts committed by advocates of pan-Arabism, a term often used for Arab imperialist and colonialist regimes, at various times. The Saddam regime’s Anfal operations against Kurds in Iraq, along with the deployment of chemical weapons, resulted in the deaths of over 100,000 Kurdish people in the late 1980s, alongside their widespread displacement and ethnic cleansing from Kurdish towns such as Kirkuk and Xaneqin. Similarly, the Syrian pan-Arabist regime has subjected Kurds to ethnic cleansing and mass expulsion, stripped over 100,000 Kurds of their citizenship in the 1960s, left them as stateless refugees, and denied them their fundamental citizenship rights. In the 2010s, with the direct and indirect help of these regimes, ISIS and other Islamist groups in Iraq and Syria attacked Kurdish-Yezidi communities. They massacred hundreds of community members and abducted 3000 Yezidi women, raping and selling them as “sex slaves” at auction. This historical experience with imperial forces provides the lens through which the Kurds understand the current Gaza war.

These regimes persist in targeting the Kurds. They perceive the Kurdish movement as an anti-Islamist and secular force in the Middle East, which both regimes view as obstacles to their imperial and colonial ambitions. The Kurds in Rojava and the KRI demonstrated their anti-Islamist approach when the armed Kurdish movements formed powerful forces to defeat ISIS. Despite ISIS’s strategy of exploiting civilians as human shields—a tactic Hamas uses in Gaza—causing thousands of civilian deaths during the war to defeat it, Kurdish troops liberated large areas from these radical Jihadists, saving the lives of thousands of people from various ethnic and religious backgrounds. Following ISIS’ military defeat, the self-proclaimed Kurdish administration proposed a more inclusive paradigm of peaceful coexistence in opposition to the homogenized, intolerant, dogmatic, dismissive, and imperialist Turkish, Persian, and Arab settings. By promoting gender equality and allowing multi-ethnic and multi-religious Kurdish-Yezidi, Assyrian and Armenian communities to practice their religious rituals and ceremonies, speak their native languages, establish their own schools, and form local self-government, they protect ethnic, linguistic, and religious diversity and have the potential to contribute to the resolution of various religious and ethnic conflicts in the Middle East. Indeed, the Kurds, like Jews, provide a governance model that includes national self-determination for indigenous populations, as well as respect for ethnic/religious minorities, in contrast to the Turkish and Iranian regimes, which not only reject this paradigm (as evidenced by decades of forced assimilation and oppression), but also implement obstructive policies and actions to eliminate it. To achieve this, both regimes have formed ideologically driven extremist Shia and Sunni Islamist alliances that threaten the existence of the Kurdish and Jewish populations and pose a challenge to Arab states wishing to engage with the the Abraham Accords. Since October 7, they have amplified this project by blaming Israel for the humanitarian catastrophe in Gaza—although Hamas brought it about with its attacks on October 7 and its strategy of exposing civilians—a form of propaganda that seeks to further derail the Abraham Accords, strengthen pro-Islamist sentiment, and target Kurds associated with the “Zionists.”

By slamming Israel, both the Iranian and Turkish regimes, as well as Syria’s Ba’ath regime, cite Kurdish ties to Israel and claim that the Kurds are establishing a second Israel, which they demonize and use as a pretext to further stifle the cultural and political Kurdish aspirations in the Middle East. To put it simply, they view the democratic, cultural, and political Kurdish aspirations as part of a “Zionist plot.” The Western powers have also abandoned the Kurds in their battle against radical jihadists and the implementation of their secular vision against the Islamic ideologies represented by the Sunni and Shia regimes. Former US president Donald Trump’s decision to withdraw American soldiers from Rojava, for instance, revealed that interest-oriented Western powers deemed the secular Kurdish vision and anti-Islamic struggle inconsequential. Despite significant human sacrifices, major Western powers have yet to recognize the Kurds in Rojava as having an autonomous status, leaving them in a state of limbo. The Jewish community in the Middle East seems to be in a similar situation, abandoned by Western powers after the American administration’s decision to question its military support for Israel. These examples illustrate that Kurds and Jews are encircled by hostile forces and cannot permanently rely on the support of Western powers. Therefore, many Kurds believe that Israeli citizens, whether Jews, Arabs, or Druze, and Kurds, along with their Yezidi and Assyrian allies, have no choice but to stand together and cooperate for their survival and for a peaceful and prosperous Middle East, one that is based on national sovereignty and respect for religious and ethnic minorities, rather than imperialism and Islamism.

Turkish and Iranian policies in the Middle East have the potential to threaten Israel’s existence and put the Kurds and other minoritized communities like the Yezidis and Assyrians at risk of yet another genocide, as in the last century. Therefore, Kurds and other minoritized peoples must critically reflect on their relationships with the Iranian, Turkish, and Arab regimes to assure that they will not face the same fate for the next century. To this end, they might consider forging a dynamic and strategic alliance with Israel in the Middle East. At the same time, Israelis must acknowledge that their regional interests, as well as security and prosperity, do not begin at the borders of Jordan, Syria, and Lebanon, their immediate neighbors, but rather at the borders of Kurdistan with Iran, Turkey, and Iraq. Peace and freedom will remain utopias when these societies fail to cooperate against a common threat to their survival. This is a viewpoint that more and more Israelis and Kurds are beginning to grasp.

 

 

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Articles

Assad May Be Gone, But Ba’athism isn’t

Dastan Jasim

The survival of the multiethnic Autonomous Administration of North and East Syria would be a litmus test for the country's future – whether it can turn the page after the Assad regime's genocidal mix of Islamism and Arab supremacy.

He Was The Future

Yoav Di-Capua

A new book analyzes the rise and fall of Nasserism—once the most powerful political movement in the Middle East, sweeping the Arab World before it disappeared into thin air.

Israel Must Win This War

Ophir Toubul

The answer to Hamas’ barbarous attack would be to press on with efforts to consolidate a “peace axis” in the Middle East, in the spirit of the Abraham Accords.

A Tolerant City?

Alex Stein

A new book sheds light on the history of medieval Jerusalem but its conclusions are ultimately unconvincing.

Islamic Law in the Lands of War

Muhammad Al-Atawneh Sabina Abdulaev

A new book - which focuses on Israel - explains the role played by Islamic law in countries where Muslims are in the minority.