A Theory for the Future

A reappraisal of Moisei Ginzburg’s seminal book "Style and Epoch" reframes the Jewish-Soviet architect’s legacy, and prompts questions about Tel Aviv’s modernist heritage.

What do architects do if their designs cannot be built; if raw materials are scarce, unemployment rampant, and money is worthless? Such was the case across Europe and the Soviet Union at the turn of the 1920s, after the First World War had ravished economies and ignited social revolutions. Many architects, therefore, took up the pen instead, drafting visionary structures to be erected in the hopeful future. Others wrote articles, edited journals, and published books looking retrospectively at the preceding decades, theorizing a new architecture for the dawning of a new society.

One prolific writer during this ascendant period of Modernism was the Jewish-Soviet architect and theoretician Moisei Ginzburg. As the twentieth century progressed, however, Ginzburg’s legacy receded, as historians focused the narrative of modernism on the luminary European protagonists Le Corbusier, Walter Gropius, and Mies van der Rohe. But as Soviet archives became more accessible to historians from the 1980s onwards, the Soviet contribution to modern art and architecture became visible, and Ginzburg’s renowned leadership among the Soviet and international avant-garde came into clear perspective.

Ginzburg’s seminal book, Style and Epoch, was published to great success in Moscow in 1924. This cultural, political, and architectural polemic laid the theoretical foundation for a Constructivist architecture—the Soviet variant of European Modernism. To commemorate the book’s centenary, I have curated a small exhibition on Ginzburg’s architectural legacy that opened this month at the Bauhaus Center in Tel Aviv. My aim is not only to direct a new spotlight on Ginzburg’s versatile architecture and prolific writings, but also to ask questions about Ginzburg’s theory and practice of Modernism within the context of Tel Aviv’s historic White City center.

 

 

Little is known about Ginzburg’s youth and Jewish upbringing in the provincial atmosphere of Minsk, where he was born in 1892. He went abroad for his architectural education, first at the Ecole des Beaux-Arts in Paris and the academy at Toulouse—he did not complete either course— before finally receiving his diploma in 1914 at the Accademia di Belli Arti in Milan. These years gave Ginzburg the opportunity to travel Europe and become acquainted with modern trends in art and architecture.

Ginzburg returned to Russia at the outbreak of the Great War and pursued, until 1917, an engineering degree at the displaced Riga Polytechnical Institute in Moscow. His mentor, Aleksander Kusnetsov, preached the use of new technology and materials in pioneering modern architectural forms. “An architect will not express his epoch,” Kusnetsov wrote in a 1915 article, “if he does not make full use of contemporary technology.” This idea resonated with Ginzburg lending impetus to his later thesis in Style and Epoch.

Ginzburg spent much of the Bolshevik Revolution in the Crimea, returning to Moscow after the revolution stabilized in 1921. By 1923 he was professor of architecture and theory at the Moscow Institute of Civil Engineering and the Higher State Art Technical Studios (Vkhutemas). The early years of the revolution were marked by a politically charged ideology of Constructivism, that sought to utilize artistic creativity for the production of utilitarian and useful everyday objects as collective tools for building the new socialist society. Ginzburg was highly immersed in the Constructivist discourse, devoting much time to scholarly study, pedagogy, and theoretical writing concerning the future of Soviet architecture.

The years following Vladimir Lenin’s 1921 New Economic Policy (NEP) saw a dramatic upturn in the Soviet economy, and the opening of new channels of cultural and economic communication with Europe. The formative years of the NEP saw Constructivist architecture being worked out in theory and on paper alone. But as the economy lifted in the second half of the 1920s, Constructivist ideals, as theorized by Ginzburg, took tangible shape in the form of avant-garde design for major State-sponsored buildings. Style and Epoch, therefore, stood as a manifesto for Constructivist architects to rally behind, and legitimized their work.

 

 

The book is deeply rooted in the evolutionary idea that culture changes and modifies over time, shedding off old, outmoded characteristics and adopting new progressive traits with each new epoch. The rise of industrialization, and the increasing prevalence of structural, machine aesthetics in the built environment, signaled for Ginzburg new progressive traits appropriate for the dawning of a new era.

Ginzburg grounded his model of cultural history in a broad reading of Charles Darwin’s theory of evolution, and in the cultural pessimism of Oswald Spengler. The first volume of Spengler’s enormously popular book, Decline of the West, was published in Germany in the summer of 1918, with the second volume in 1922. The entire work was translated into Russian and published in Moscow in 1923. Spengler’s pessimistic rhetoric viewed culture as a living organism, one that passed through the seasons of life until, like all living organisms, it eventually died out.

This popular mode of cultural philosophy had origins as far back as the Italian historian Giorgio Vasari who wrote during the Italian Renaissance that artistic periods, “like human beings themselves, are born, grow up, become old, and die.” The mantle of cultural pessimism was then reinvigorated in the eighteenth century under the German philosophers Arthur Schopenhauer and Friedrich Nietzsche. Indeed, as the European continent plummeted into destructive war between 1914 and 1918, many believed that they were witnessing the death stages of their current enlightened epoch, birthed in the Renaissance. As the French writer Paul Valéry acutely noted in his 1919 article “The Crisis of the Mind,” “We see now that the abyss of history is deep enough to hold us all. We are aware that a civilization has the same fragility as a life.”

Ginzburg’s polemic incorporated the elements of art and architectural style into the life-cycles of civilization. Through this evolutionary process, positive characteristics of culture and architectural aesthetics are retained from past styles, while negative characteristics disappear over time as they no longer reflect the new era. In this life cycle, the birth stages of a new architectural style are strictly utilitarian, manifested by buildings designed from simple structural necessity devoid of any surface decoration. The maturing stages organically combine the youthful structural aesthetic and surface decoration without one overpowering the other, while the final declining stages are marked by pure decorative independence.

Ginzburg identified rapid industrialization and specifically the function of the machine, which had energized the opening of the twentieth century, as the prime indicator of the temperament of his time. Structural and utilitarian architectural forms had previously been commonplace in industrial buildings like grain silos, power plants, and factories. But as Constructivist architects began to appropriate this industrial aesthetic into their commissioned projects in the early 1920s, Ginzburg understood this as indicative of the birth of a new style. The era of classical hegemony, as seen in the historicised and overly ornamented buildings of imperialist Europe and Russia in the nineteenth century, had come to an end. The opening of a new epoch was indicated by the rise of new utilitarian and structural architecture. In this manner, Ginzburg also paid an overt debt to the influential German historian Heinrich Wölfflin, who asserted that each era must embody its unique zeitgeist, its spirit of the times, through art and architectural expression.

 

 

Style and Epoch received an overwhelmingly popular reception among architects and the Moscow intelligentsia when it was published in 1924. The Leningrad architect and city planner Professor V.K. Karpovich reviewed the book for the city’s journal Questions of the Communal Economy. “In an excellent book of Ginzburg the reader will find not only theoretical discussions on style in architecture, but also absolutely practical approaches to the creative problems of contemporary architecture.” Karpovich concluded that “the study of the machine can give a new stimulus to the creation of new architectural forms.” Likewise, historian Catherine Cooke—arguably the authority in Russian and Soviet architecture—noted that the “breadth and sophistication” of Style and Epoch was appreciated by “leading members of the cultural intelligentsia” and found resonance in Ginzburg’s “similarly educated Moscow circle.”

The cultural model outlined in Style and Epoch gave Constructivist architects of the 1920s a strong sense of historical legitimacy—that they were actively participating in the progressive course of history, rather than remaining stagnant in the past. The book equally gave architects confidence to dismiss the historicized trends of nineteenth century architecture, characterized by decorative facades and ornamental motifs, as signs of a dying culture. As Ginzburg stated in Style and Epoch, “self-sufficient aestheticism lies as a heavy burden on us that establishes the genetic role of moribund European culture: these are its last days.” In moving forward, Ginzburg’s theory encouraged architects to openly embrace new experiments in structural and utilitarian design, using new industrial material such as reinforced concrete, glass, and steel.

The book may have seemed a novelty to the Moscow public but Ginzburg’s criteria of a new architecture mirrored the simultaneous development of the Modern Movement in Europe, later to be known as the International Style. European modernists were also promoting new architecture stripped of historical reference, devoid of surface ornament and constructed with new industrial materials. At the vanguard was Le Corbusier in Paris, who Ginzburg admired and overtly mimicked. For example, scholars such as Jean-Louis Cohen have pointed out that the pages in Style and Epoch mimicked the pages in Le Corbusier’s ground-breaking 1923 book Toward a New Architecture. Some of the images published in Ginzburg’s book—such as grain silos in New York, steamships, airplanes, and factory buildings—were first published in the pages of Le Corbusier’s journal L’Esprit nouveau. Ginzburg had access to this publication, and other European journals, after the limited channels of cultural communication with Western Europe opened during the early NEP years. Likewise, the archives at the Fondation Le Corbusier in Paris contains a first edition of Style and Epoch, personalized on the cover page from Ginzburg to Le Corbusier, although it is doubtful the French architect could read the Russian text.

 

 

Further testament to Style and Epoch’s influence and the success of Constructivism can be seen in Ginzburg’s architectural activity in the second half of the 1920s. By 1926, he had assumed leadership, together with Alexander Vesnin, of the Constructivist group Union of Contemporary Architects (OSA). Vesnin was also a major proponent of Constructivism in practice and theory, whose 1922 “Credo” incited artists and architects to look to “general objects” such as ‘bridges, locomotives, airplanes, [and] cranes” as influential signifiers for “pure construction, without the weight of décor.” As edited the OSA’s journal Sovremennaia arkitektura (Contemporary Architecture), Ginzburg also established solid links with the leading modernists in France, the Netherlands, and Germany.

The four major buildings that Ginzburg designed and built in the second half of the 1920s are clear examples of how he adapted theory into practice, and stand as pristine exhibits of Constructivist architecture with close affinities to European modernist trends. Three residential buildings—Gosstrakh (Moscow, 1926-27), Narkomfin (Moscow, 1928-32), and Communal House (Moscow, 1929-31)—were commissioned by the State as experimental “social condensers,” intended to transition urban residencies towards communal living. The fourth building—Government House (Almaty, 1927-31)—served as the Soviet regime’s bureaucratic office in Kazakhstan.

The Narkomfin was commissioned to house workers for the Commissariat of Finance, and is arguably Ginzburg’s most famous building. By 1934, however, Joseph Stalin’s regime mandated the official State art and architectural style to be a monumental neoclassicism known as Socialist Realism, thus downgrading Constructivism and European Modernism. Over the course of the twentieth century, the Narkomfin was abandoned and neglected; by the turn of the twenty-first century, the building sat vacant and dilapidated. In 2016 the decrepit building was bought by the Russian company Rights League (Liga Prava) who hired Moisei Ginzburg’s grandson, the architect Alexey Ginzburg (Ginzburg Architects) to restore the building to its original design, as a real estate venture for private apartments. The restoration was completed in 2020. Simultaneously, Ginzburg Architects partnered with Fontanka Publishing in London to translate and republish Moisei Ginzburg’s three books. Rhythm in Architecture, originally published in 1923, Style and Epoch from 1924, and 1934’s Dwelling, were all rereleased in 2017 in new English translations by John Nicolson.

 

 

The legacy of 1920s modernism did not remain exclusively in Europe and the Soviet Union; nor did it die out after totalitarian regimes in Berlin and Moscow deemed it “degenerate” in the 1930s. Many Jewish architects fleeing anti-Semitism in Europe imported modern architectural theories and trends to Mandate Palestine when they immigrated during the fourth and fifth Aliyot, in the 1920s and 1930s. It has been well recorded, by historians such as Michael Levin and Herbert Gilbert, that many of the architects who imported Modernism to Jerusalem, Haifa, and Tel Aviv had trained under Le Corbusier, at the Bauhaus, or in the offices of other Berlin modernists.

The question that is yet to be fully examined is whether Ginzburg’s theories and buildings had any direct or indirect influence during this transfer of modernism. We know that Ginzburg’s work from the 1920s was published in European journals and praised by European architects. Student exchanges in 1926 between the Bauhaus and the Vkhutemas, where Ginzburg was still teaching, would have also disseminated Ginzburg’s prestige further. One Bauhaus student who visited the Vkhutemas in 1927 was Arieh Sharon. Later, after his return to Mandate Palestine in 1931, Sharon was to become the prime actor in the design of modernist buildings in Tel Aviv. Ginzburg was also invited to represent the Soviet Union at the 1928 International Congress of Modern Architecture in La Sarraz, Switzerland, where the leading practitioners of modernism gathered to consolidate unity and exchange ideas and influence. Even without concrete evidence, it is fair to speculate that Ginzburg’s continental reputation and influence also arrived indirectly to Mandate Palestine, with the importation of European trends.

A 1992 study at the Technion by Gilbert Herbert and Ita Heinze Greenberg revealed that of the 456 immigrants who registered in Mandate Palestine as “architect,” 109 came from Soviet Russia. Among the many reasons for Russian immigration, according to Herbert and Greenberg, was “reacting to the Bolshevik revolution in Russia.” Even though Ginzburg unabashedly embraced his Jewish heritage, no evidence has turned up of any particular sympathy to the Zionist project in Mandate Palestine or of his interest in immigrating. While many tried to flee the Soviet Union, Ginzburg enjoyed steady employment as a Constructivist architect during Stalin’s regime.

Even after Stalin banned Modernism in his decree of Socialist Realism, Ginzburg modified his practice, remaining active and relevant in the profession until his death in 1946. While rejecting the classical aesthetic that is often a key characteristic of Socialist Realism, Ginzburg remained true to the basic theory outlined in Style and Epoch by modifying Constructivism into a conservative functional style. “Functional architecture,” Ginzburg stated in 1933, at the dawn of Stalin’s decree, “will be carried out by a few who have the courage, firmness, and know-how to correctly understand the historical heritage of the past, and can use this heritage in real life.”

While many view Ginzburg’s shift away from orthodox Constructivism as accommodating Stalin’s totalitarianism, it could also be viewed as testament to Ginzburg’s ingenuity and versatile professionalism. The current exhibition that I have curated at the Bauhaus Center in Tel Aviv looks at Ginzburg’s entire body of work as a highly versatile portfolio. Aesthetic differences are indeed noticeable between the Constructivist buildings of the 1920s and the conservative monumentalism of the 1930s and 1940s. The commonality that unites Ginzburg’s oeuvre, however, is an unrelenting theoretical commitment to harnessing aesthetics and utility as appropriate expressions of the contemporary era.

 

 

“Moisei Ginzburg: Soviet Architecture and Dwelling” opened 10 November 2024 at the Bauhaus Center Tel Aviv, 77 Dizengoff Street, Tel Aviv.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Articles

Tel Aviv: City of Torah and Hasidism

Yitzhak Bar Ze'ev

Known as Israel's secular city, Tel Aviv actually has a rich religious past and present.